If we re looking for random rust rust python boundary things

Question

If we re looking for random rust rust python boundary things I d really like `$ pants ldebug cloc src python pants version` to where it currently prints ``` 18 37 22 DEBUG engine scheduler Root Select ExecuteProcessRequest argv lt HashableTypedCollection Exactly str gt = usr bin perl bin cloc 1 66 cloc skip uniqueness ignored=ignored list file=input files list report file=report input files lt Exactly Digest gt =Digest fingerprint=bafbaf573c6f8f698926645eeba3b7ebfc5bd4d3ce1d05bf0333df475fd1b6ef serialized bytes length=326 description lt Exactly str gt =cloc env lt HashableTypedCollection Exactly str gt = output files lt HashableTypedCollection Exactly str gt = ignored report output directories lt HashableTypedCollection Exactly str gt = timeout seconds lt Exactly float or int gt =900 jdk home lt Exactly str or NoneType gt =None FallibleExecuteProcessResult completed ``` to instead print ``` 18 37 22 DEBUG engine scheduler Root Select ExecuteProcessRequest description=cloc FallibleExecuteProcessResult completed ``` trimming down the output from a full dump of a repr of a python object to a targeted informational representation of a python object This may tie in nicely with <https github com pantsbuild pants issues 7745> while also crossing the rust python boundary

witty-crayon-22786 · Answer

it might but that also touches UX stuff cc < red balloon 89377>

witty-crayon-22786 · Answer

in general we think that we are very likely to need rule author annotations to manually indicate that an rule is worth rendering

average-vr-56795 · Answer

And relatedly This is how you should render me if I m worth rendering slightly smiling face

witty-crayon-22786 · Answer

< hundreds breakfast 49010> which is related to the output of ` pants no v1 v2 v2 ui test $a pure python test` which < red balloon 89377> worked on most recently

witty-crayon-22786 · Answer

right exactly

witty-crayon-22786 · Answer

basically we re using debug output for things that we hope to not use it for very long because there are other plans

red-balloon-89377 · Answer

I think figuring out a principled way for rules to say that they should be rendered is a nice self contained ticket that shouldn t require too much synchronization with the resto if the UI work

witty-crayon-22786 · Answer

yea < red balloon 89377> if you have time to create that ticket it would be very appreciated

witty-crayon-22786 · Answer

it s also possible that Greg could work on the remove interleaving portion of the UX work

red-balloon-89377 · Answer

Sure thing

witty-crayon-22786 · Answer

maybe removing interleaving is a more obvious thing because it would give us somewhere useful to render this new information

red-balloon-89377 · Answer

That s a bit trickier because it involves solving the how do we want or do we want at all to stream test results

witty-crayon-22786 · Answer

we don t plan to anytime soon

red-balloon-89377 · Answer

Because it s really easy if we want to dump stdout at the end

red-balloon-89377 · Answer

But really hard if we need to sync on every test result

red-balloon-89377 · Answer

If we re going with option A for now dump everything at the end I prototyped some of that at the beginning of may can certainly create another ticket

witty-crayon-22786 · Answer

< red balloon 89377> this is mostly already designed

witty-crayon-22786 · Answer

in and which refer to

witty-crayon-22786 · Answer

i believe that that is all still relevant right now ie we re still punting on streaming test output

witty-crayon-22786 · Answer

< hundreds breakfast 49010> if you haven t read the v2 output HLD 3rd link above you can get access to that google doc by joining `pants devel `

red-balloon-89377 · Answer

Cool I can create both of those tickets

red-balloon-89377 · Answer

I meant that I have a sketch of a solution for synchronization between Logger and Console in the UI

witty-crayon-22786 · Answer

< red balloon 89377> one of the above is still open as well Maybe noving out the part that is still relevant into a new ticket

witty-crayon-22786 · Answer

Ah cool

red-balloon-89377 · Answer

One issue created with a part of 6004 cc < hundreds breakfast 49010>

red-balloon-89377 · Answer

I have opened <https github com pantsbuild pants issues 7907> to discuss the requirements of how and when are rules displayed I have some implementation ideas but I want to be really sure that we agree on the requirements