Hi Pants We are having a small issue with ` pants fmt` It sa

Question

Hi Pants We are having a small issue with ` pants fmt` It says that black and isort made changes however it doesn t really change any files the command is just ` pants fmt filepath` Meanwhile if we run `black filepath` actual changes are made

ambitious-student-81104 · Answer

Commands and outputs ``` pants fmt myfile py 11 23 01 77 INFO Completed Format with docformatter Docformatter made no changes 11 23 01 77 WARN Completed Format with isort isort made changes Fixing myfile py 11 23 01 77 WARN Completed Format with Black Black made changes reformatted myfile py All done 1 file reformatted + Black made changes Docformatter made no changes + isort made changes git status On branch xxx Your branch is up to date with origin xxx nothing to commit working tree clean black myfile py reformatted myfile py All done 1 file reformatted git status On branch xxx Your branch is up to date with origin xxx Changes not staged for commit use git add lt file gt to update what will be committed use git restore lt file gt to discard changes in working directory modified myfile py```

ambitious-student-81104 · Answer

`pants toml` config ``` black args = line length=100 isort config = isort cfg ```

ambitious-student-81104 · Answer

This hasn t happened to us before which makes this case interesting

hundreds-father-404 · Answer

Hello My first thought would be if isort and black are overwriting each other Have you configured them to be compatible If you run them both directly without Pants does it work as you expect

ambitious-student-81104 · Answer

gt Have you configured them to be compatible they ve been compatible so far but that s likely When I run black alone it does make changes to the imports

ambitious-student-81104 · Answer

maybe this is an edge case we just ran into for the first time I ll check that and report back thanks Eric

ambitious-student-81104 · Answer

What is the suggestion to make isort and black compatible is `profile = black ` sufficient

hundreds-father-404 · Answer

ambitious-student-81104 · Answer

yep looks like that s what it takes