#general
- w
witty-crayon-22786
10/09/2015, 7:35 PMthe halfway doesn't seem useful, and the fullway is hard - w
witty-crayon-22786
10/09/2015, 7:35 PM(...to implement) - w
witty-crayon-22786
10/09/2015, 7:35 PM(maybe? with npm) - b
bright-dinner-81701
10/09/2015, 7:35 PMso just making it Pants work with shrinkwrap, and devs do “npm shrinkwrap” and check npm-shinkwrap.json into source? - b
bright-dinner-81701
10/09/2015, 7:35 PMbc that works and it isnt that hard - e
enough-analyst-54434
10/09/2015, 7:35 PMNot sure on the details - e
enough-analyst-54434
10/09/2015, 7:36 PMBut conceptually pants should shrinkwrap the resolve - b
bright-dinner-81701
10/09/2015, 7:36 PMi see - w
witty-crayon-22786
10/09/2015, 7:36 PMpossibly that's a decent middle ground. the shrinkwrap file would need to go outside.pants.d - e
enough-analyst-54434
10/09/2015, 7:36 PMwhether that uses shrinkwrap or does it itself or interoperates if present - e
enough-analyst-54434
10/09/2015, 7:36 PMThe thing we're all talking past is the scope - w
witty-crayon-22786
10/09/2015, 7:36 PMbut having the shrinkwrap implemented as generated BUILD files is likely where we're headed for other languages - e
enough-analyst-54434
10/09/2015, 7:37 PMtypical shrinkwraps do so for a thing, not for a repo of many things - b
bright-dinner-81701
10/09/2015, 7:37 PMright - w
witty-crayon-22786
10/09/2015, 7:37 PM@enough-analyst-54434: buck and bazel's are both for the whole repo - e
enough-analyst-54434
10/09/2015, 7:37 PMFor Node? - w
witty-crayon-22786
10/09/2015, 7:38 PMdoesn't exist for node, iirc. now i'm using shrinkwrap like kleenex - b
bright-dinner-81701
10/09/2015, 7:38 PM@witty-crayon-22786: you cant do it for the whole repo with NPM - w
witty-crayon-22786
10/09/2015, 7:38 PM@bright-dinner-81701: sure you can. generate a sufficiently large package.json and you can move the world - b
bright-dinner-81701
10/09/2015, 7:38 PMhah - b
bright-dinner-81701
10/09/2015, 7:38 PMlike the results of an install depend on the full context of the package.json - w
witty-crayon-22786
10/09/2015, 7:39 PMyou know all possible contexts within the repo - b
bright-dinner-81701
10/09/2015, 7:39 PMoh - w
witty-crayon-22786
10/09/2015, 7:39 PMit's a closed world. - b
bright-dinner-81701
10/09/2015, 7:39 PMwell - b
bright-dinner-81701
10/09/2015, 7:39 PMuhh im not sure how one big package.json works - e
enough-analyst-54434
10/09/2015, 7:39 PMThe fact that classpaths are trees and not lists makes extra work here for Node that does not exist for any other system we've dealt with so far - e
enough-analyst-54434
10/09/2015, 7:40 PM"~trees" - e
enough-analyst-54434
10/09/2015, 7:40 PMThey are not flat things - b
bored-art-40741
10/09/2015, 7:40 PMhills?